Witness #5 - Pat Gonzales

Unfortunately, we are unable to show a video of the testimony given by the meat delivery witness, Pat Gonzales.  Below is a short summary of his testimony in this case during the trial.


My name is Pat Gonzales.  I see Sandy Townsend three times a week when I deliver meat to her restaurant. I deliver 100 lbs. each visit or 300 lbs. per week.  At 8 a.m. in the morning, I came in and unloaded my delivery.  Then, I sat down and had a cup of coffee with Sandy.  They never make me pay for coffee, like many of my other customers.  


We were sitting there talking and Terese Jameson came in.  Sandy and Terese went into the back office for 15 minutes.  When they returned, I went in the back with Sandy to her office to give her a receipt and collect the check.  I then proceeded to leave through the back door.  I did not hear any yelling.  I was only 20 feet from the back of the restaurant where Terese and Sandy were talking.  I would have definitely heard yelling if they had been an argument.  I did not see any blood or signs of a struggle when I left out the back of the restaurant.  Nothing was a miss.  


I saw a number of teenagers hanging around the dumpster being loud.  I thought it was suspicious since they should have been in school at that time of the day.  


I did not see Sandy kill Terese. 


I did work for Sandy Townsend prior to my job at Prime Cuts as a delivery driver for her grocery store.  I was picked up for drunk driving while in her employment and Sandy Townsend bailed me out of jail.  She did not report this incident in a letter of recommendation to my current employer.


I did see Terese Jameson arrive late to work many times when I was at the Silver Streak Cafe.   I would be in there at 8 a.m., when she was supposed to be in work, and Sandy would be short handed.  Since Sandy does not use pre-made hamburger patties, she would fall behind because Terese did not arrive to work on time.

Comments

The testimony provided by Pat Gonzales who was the meat delivery man which frequently delivered 100 lbs. of meat three times a week to the defendants restaurant, used a great deal of fallacy in his testimony.

Specifically a faulty sign fallacy, this particular type of fallacy wrongly assumes that one event or phenomenon is a reliable indicator or predictor of another event or phenomenon. Mr. Gonzales testified that upon his exit through the back door he did not hear any yelling between Sandy and Terese or witness any blood or signs of struggle. Mr. Gonzales did however testify that upon his exit of the restaurant he witnessed a number of teenagers hanging around the dumpster being loud. He went on to mention that he thought it was suspicious since they should have been in school at that time of day. This statement regarding the whereabouts of these teenagers during school hours implies that because they were not in school they possibly had an involvement in the murder. Mr. Gonzales’s statement wrongly assumes the event of these loud teenagers hanging around the dumpster is a reliable indicator that they may be involved in foul play.

Article written by MSTC Student, David Garcia